Rick roderick on epicureans, stoics, and skeptics full. Here are the differences between stoics and epicureans. Get an answer for compare and contrast epicurean and stoic philosophy. Bad things of course is a very subjunctive way of putting it, but in short, it is being immoral and unethical. Start studying epicureanism vs stoicism vs cynicism. In the former category, the most prominent is the fear of death.
Epicureanism vs stoicism vs cynicism arts and humanities. Both sought to be selfsufficient and unaffected by externals. Pdf the stoic and the epicurean philosophy on the good life. Ive read a couple other sets similar to this and was very happy to find this one. The stoics epictetus, marcus aurelius, advocate a philosophy of renunciation, an acceptance of fate. An epicurean and stoic perspective a guest submission by wendy kosek. Epicureanism flourished in the late hellenistic era and during the roman era, and many epicurean communities were established, such as those in antiochia, alexandria, rhodes, and herculaneum. Unlike epicurean, the sense of the english adjective stoical is not. Stoics, by not responding at least externally and emotionally to the consequences of fate, either pleasurable or painful. Epicureanism emerged at roughly the same time as stoicism, which was founded by zeno of citium c.
The universe is the result of random combinations of atoms into four elements, and elements into existing matter. Epicureans definition and meaning bible dictionary. Both were fashionable in the roman era, stoicism in romes early time, more forceful years and lifelong among the level and file of roman population, and epicureanism at the back of closed doors, particularly at the highest levels of the territory. A case of this philosophical dichotomy that was particularly well thought and well fought was.
Because of the moral theories, the epicurean live in their own society where they limit their desires. The stoic and the epicurean philosophy on the good life. What is the difference between an epicurean and a hedonist. Epicureans difference between stoics and epicureans. The site thus covers the main philosophical traditions, from the presocratic to the contemporary philosophers, while trying to bring a philosophical reading to the cultural field in general, such as cinema, literature, politics or music. They both advocate seeking happiness from an internal source, so that the ups and downs of life will not be your masters. Epicurean vs stoics epicurean vs stoic moral theories the. In verse 28 paul quotes a stoic poet, aratus, for we are indeed his offspring. This philosophy was a system of atheism, and taught men to seek as their highest aim a pleasant and smooth life. Stoics, epicureans and sceptics the classical astrologer. They accepted the physics of democritus that the universe was composed entirely of empty space filled with atoms of differing shapes and weights that what are the main differences between epicureanism and stoicism. No, its conclusions are familiar for another reasonthey sound like those of modern secular culture. The stoic position is that the wise man is selfsufficient but that he prefers to have friends, fate permitting.
Buddhism was founded in presentday nepal around 500 b. According to zeno, the first stoic, we are to become indifferent to pleasure and pain, wealth and poverty, health and illness, indeed, life and death themselves. The epicurean paradigm is rule based, not system based. Epicureanism revolves purely around pleasure, but people can achieve pleasure by doing bad things. Epictetus judges epicurus by reference to the stoic thesis that the desire to benefit others and to engage in familial and communal life forms a natural part of human development see introd. Oct 26, 2018 an epicurean is a hedonist but a hedonist is not necessarily an epicurean, and the popular conception of hedonism certainly does not accurately describe epicureanism nor does the popular conception of epicureanism. The cambridge companion to epicureanism edited by james warren frontmatter more information.
Stoic wisdom is all about doing your duty as reason and nature direct your reflective actions. They accepted the physics of democritus that the universe was composed entirely of empty space filled with atoms of differing shapes and weights that. Epicureanism was introduced into rome in the early second. There is no qualitative difference between god and the rest of the universe 21. Regardless of the few times epicureanism stumbled upon the truth, the materialistic views of epicureanism directly contradict the bible. At its cradle to repeat a thoughtful adage religion stands, and philosophy accompanies it to the grave. Stoics, epicureans and sceptics provides an introduction to the subject for all who are interested in understanding the significance of this period of ancient thought. Jan 20, 2017 by the ninth letter, seneca is openly criticising epicureanism, however. Jan 02, 2020 one of the groups that debated with paul on the streets of athens was epicurean acts 17. Which lifestyle, epicurean or stoic, achieves the greatest amount of happiness. Later its main opponent became stoicism some writings by epicurus have survived. This is one view cyclical conflagrations and recreations. Epicurean empiricism prefigured that of locke, berkeley, and hume.
Epicureanism advocates a minimum happiness, but a philosophy of the will. The history of philosophy is constantly punctuated with battles between two practically orthogonal ways of thinking. Beyond this quotation and the fact that they rejected the idea of a bodily resurrection, luke gives no information about their views. Of course, the truth that the epicurean drew from nature completely ignored the fact of a present, lifesustaining creator. He has published widely in classical studies and philosophy. Publication date 1910 topics epicurus, stoics, philosophy, ancient. The stoics were characterized by their materialism, their theodicy and their rejection of passions and desires. Stoic as well as the epicurean philosophic schools rose in. To the epicureans, the gods were more viewed as rolemodels than powers to be bribed or appeased. Stoic beliefs differ from epicurean morals in at least three traditions. Sabrina decides to go because there are some people she wants to get advice from some wise friends. Gautama buddha of all people only those are at leisure who make time for philosophy, only those are really alive.
The stoics did, in fact, hold that emotions like fear or envy or. Epicurean vs stoics epicurean vs stoic moral theories. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. If so, how is it defined, is it attainable, and how.
Of all the philosophical schools active during hellenistic times, stoicism had. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. The epicurean sage, or one who has attained the ideal which epicureanism sets forth, is one who, given that his basic needs are met shelter, food, etc. Aug 26, 2012 rick roderick on epicureans, stoics, and skeptics full length the partially examined life. They accepted the physics of democritus that the universe was composed entirely of empty space filled with atoms of differing shapes and w. What are the main differences between epicureanism and stoicism. Epicureanism gets its name from epicurus 341 270 b. She has been featured by npr and national geographic for her ancient history expertise. Sep 29, 2010 the garden had a carefullydesigned program of advertising and education to attract and instruct students, and those whoaccepted epicurean teachings were encouraged to formally proclaim their epicurean identity, build friendships with each other, revere the founders of the garden as rolemodels, and celebrate specifically epicurean festivals.
Rick roderick on epicureans, stoics, and skeptics full length the partially examined life. Apr 06, 2011 a modern epicurean would prefer market forces to the political. For example, if a person wants to choose between going to. If i had to choice between being an epicurean or a stoic, i think i would choose stoicism. The epicureans were materialists in the modern, scientific sense.
First, democritus had apparently held that when atoms combine to form a body such. Gill is a latinist, writer, and teacher of ancient history and latin. The active elements, or at least the principles of hot and cold, combine to form breath or pneuma. Pdf the stoic and the epicurean philosophy on the good. There would also be a visceral opposition to the supreme court taking an innovative and creative interpretation of the constitution. They accepted the physics of democritus that the universe was composed entirely of empty space filled with atoms of differing shapes and weights that moved in nonlinear paths swerving smashing together and latching into greater structures, composing the universe. Eric decides to go because he wants to drink some wine and relax.
The logos became another word in the stoic system for god, since it maintains order ferguson, p. He introduces readers to the fundamental ways in which happiness is created within the two philosophical perspectives, by juxtaposing the schools of thought to highlight criticisms and commonality between the two. Epicureanism was originally a challenge to platonism. Mar 18, 2011 for the early stoics, the art of living meant cultivating ataraxia or painlessness, and this meant becoming indifferent to the things most people crave the most. What are the main differences between epicureanism and. These philosophers followed the teachings of epicurus, 341270. There is practical comparison between stoicism and epicureanism, in spite of their theoretical differences. Because of the moral theories, the epicurean live in their own society where they limit their desires to live a happy life.
In fact, it even came close to anticipating the idealism of. In a way, the epicurean view was pretty close to deism in this regard. They, with the stoics, ridiculed the teaching of paul acts 17. Sharples holds a personal chair in classics at university college london. Theres a big party on saturday night hosted by alcibiades, and he invites sabrina the stoic and eric the epicurean.
True religion is contemplation of all things with a peaceful mind. Stoic philosophers, in contrast to epicureans, believed that there are many things outside of our control in life, and therefore many things which. The constitution is a set of rules that should not be changed. Epicureanismstoicism epicurus was a great philosopher that founded the epicurean belief. The founder and namesake of the epicurean school was epicurus 341270 bce. The garden had a carefullydesigned program of advertising and education to attract and instruct students, and those whoaccepted epicurean teachings were encouraged to formally proclaim their epicurean identity, build friendships with each other, revere the founders of the garden as rolemodels, and celebrate specificallyepicurean festivals. They have been called the sadducees of greek paganism. Epicurean moral theories were to avoid all pain that can bring suffering to the human beings. We already know that the stoics had much in common with the early christians. Stoic a comparison chart with citations to sources in the ancient texts see also a comparison chart on the goal of life issue epicurean philosophy stoicism 1 does truth exist. Epicurus, founder of the school of philosophy called epicureanism. Heres another narrative to understand the distinctions. The wikipedia page on epicureanism has a decent section on epicurean theology.
Phil 125 epicurus vs stoics free will stoicism scribd. He rejects the epicurean doctrine that the wise man needs friends to achieve the goal of living a truly pleasant life, free from fear and pain. There are many differences moral conception of man, ontology, metaphysics, between epicureanism and stoicism, two of the most known philosophy schools. An epicurean is a hedonist but a hedonist is not necessarily an epicurean, and the popular conception of hedonism certainly does not accurately describe epicureanism nor does the popular conception of epicureanism. Epicureanism is a system of philosophy founded around 307 bc based upon the teachings of the ancient greek philosopher epicurus. Phil 125 epicurus vs stoics free download as word doc. This volume gathers together the most important evidence about stoic thought surviving from the ancient world. One was to show indifference to either pleasure or pain and mastery over all. In the passage below from the book letters from a stoic, seneca, a stoic who appreciated the philosophy of epicureanism, noted the main difference between his stoic school and the school of epicurus.
By the late 3rd century ce epicureanism all but died out, being opposed by other philosophies mainly neoplatonism that were now in the ascendant. See all 62 formats and editions hide other formats and editions. What seneca really said about epicureanism donald robertson. In his book stoics, epicureans and skeptics, classicist r. Difference between stoics and epicureans stoics vs. From the conquests of alexander the great, greece started began its greatest cultural expansion in history. Nov 27, 2009 if i had to choice between being an epicurean or a stoic, i think i would choose stoicism. Stoicism and buddhism are two remarkably similar philosophies that were created independently thousands of miles apart. God, zeus, creative fire, ether, the word logos, reason of the world, soul of the world, law of nature, providence, destiny, and order. By the ninth letter, seneca is openly criticising epicureanism, however. All the ideal, knowledge and greek values were made known in other regions and cultures totally different. Epicurean philosophy generally involved a minimalist approach to the acquisition of material things. Stoics used an allegorical method of interpretation. The rejection of the epicurean ideal of pleasure in late.
Read compare and contrast epicureanism and stoicism on. Oct 31, 20 as you can see, epicureanism disagreed with christianity on an awful lot. Stoic, epicurean and indeed sceptic ideas have come to form an important part of our own cultural backgroundoften misunderstood or altered, but then which thoughts of earlier generations are immune to that. For a fuller and more nuanced account of epicurean thinking on society, see ls 22. Epicureanism is a philosophy which stresses the importance of training ones desires. The universe will end when one element earth, air, fire, water totally dominates. Epicureanism taught that the highest state a person could attain was ataraxia absolute peaceand aponia complete absence of mental, emotional, and physical. The hostile reaction can however only be understood in terms of the history in the twentieth century of study of this period. Knowledge is empirically gainedthey believed in tabula rosa of the soul. Often criticisms of epicurean philosophy merge with more general criticisms made against those who treat pleasure as the goal of life.
It is an expanded version of the section on stoicism in inwood and gersons hellenistic philosophy, consolidating related texts into larger, more continuous selections, adding material on the skeptical attack on stoicism, and a short section that introduces the reader to some of the. Stoic moral theories the epicurean and the stoics has a very different moral theories then each other. Read compare and contrast epicureanism and stoicism on pain. Publication date 1910 topics epicurus, stoics, philosophy, ancient publisher new york. Stoic and epicurean paperback november 12, 2009 by r.
The art of living, for the stoics, means following the universal laws of nature and facing whatever comes your way with equanimity, neither exulting in victory nor despairing in defeat. C and stoicism began in athens, greece around 300 b. Stoic logic can in many respects be regarded as a forerunner of modern propositional logic. After plato and aristotle, the concerns of the philosophers moved further and further from metaphysics, epistemology, and anything resembling modern science, to the issue that had always concerned the ancient greeks the most ethics. Popularity, however, is where the similarity between the two ends. The epicureans the epicureans were materialists in the modern, scientific sense. Stoic and epicurean by hicks, robert drew, 18501929. In the time of zeno, the founder of stoicism, this probably began with attacks against the cyrenaic school of philosophy, and later expanded to encompass the teachings of epicurus. For the stoics, selfprotection is the first natural character while pleasure plays this responsibility for the epicureans. In the beginning of all cultures a strong religious faith conceals and softens the nature of things, and gives men courage to bear pain and hardship patiently. Compare and contrast epicurean and stoic philosophy. In ancient greece, epicurean philosophy and the philosophy of stoicism were popular movements.
445 524 1330 264 150 942 190 918 501 577 1012 1513 892 1438 1451 318 1335 1447 286 68 435 312 1313 925 1437 915 70 1473 858 1071 242 593 1333 641 1230 896 240 881 400 402 897 249 1197 340 825 245 383 842